What does it mean for something to 'count' as religion? For NeoPagans, whose spiritual practices defy conventional definitions, this question becomes deeply personal. In a society that often demands clear boundaries and legal frameworks for religion, how do we articulate the sacredness of casting a circle, honoring ancestors, or leaving offerings at a tree? Drawing inspiration from The Impossibility of Religious Freedom, this reflection explores the challenges of recognition and the power of 'lived religion'—the spontaneous, deeply personal acts that connect us to the Divine and each other. Let’s embrace the beautiful complexity of our paths and create spaces where all expressions of faith can flourish.